President Obama never was shy about using his phone and pen to achieve what he could not get from Congress on regulatory matters.
But documents revealed last week show the Obama administration may have been willing to get around congressional decisions on spending by using a slush fund of sorts funded by the profits of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, the two government-sponsored home loan giants.
Fannie and Freddie are federally chartered enterprises which buy mortgage loans from banks and bundle them into securities that are sold to investors, thus freeing up capital so that banks can make more home loans.
They are government-sponsored enterprises, which means the government guarantees their loans. But they are run as private enterprises, with private leadership, a board of directors and, most significantly for this purpose, investors. They’re even listed on the stock market.
In response to the mortgage crisis of 2008, Congress passed the Housing and Economic Recovery Act, which provided $187.5 billion in government loans for Fannie and Freddie and placed them in conservatorship under the newly established Federal Housing Finance Agency.
But Fannie and Freddie were not in such bad shape after all, and in just a few years, they were turning profits and on course to pay back the government with interest and still have money to pay dividends to their investors.
In 2012, the Obama administration came up with a plan to divert those profits to the Treasury that became known as the Net Worth Sweep. Officials said the profits had to be diverted back into the Treasury because Fannie and Freddie were in a “death spiral” and would have to return for loans, and this money would be used for those loans. In other words, Treasury would take all the profits from Fannie and Freddie and hold them for future loans when they again found themselves in trouble.
But — the administration knew Fannie and Freddie were healthy for the long term, were unlikely to need any more loans and, in fact, had enough money to pay dividends. The dividends were a problem for the administration because it made it hard to explain why it needed to abscond with Fannie and Freddie’s $241 billion in profits, execute an improper taking against the shareholders, and spend the money without congressional approval. Some even pushed to change accounting methods to make Fannie and Freddie look worse on paper and/or force them to “need” loans to survive.
In 2013, Fairholme Funds, one of those investors, filed suit, charging that, in sweeping the money back into the Treasury rather than pay dividends as required by law, the government exceeded its authority and ignored the law’s requirements that it conserve the assets of the enterprises. The government’s response indicates Fairholme’s accusations are probably dead on.
One of the documents released last week said the proposal to sweep the funds into Treasury would have “three primary benefits:”
It would “eliminate the circularity of Treasury funding the GSE’s dividends payments to Treasury.” It would “…capture all future earnings at the GSEs to help pay back taxpayers for their investment in those firms,” and it would “reduce future draws… so such draws would only be made when needed to fund quarterly net losses.”
The administration could have “eliminated the circularity” by following the law and paying the dividends. There is no legal basis for unilaterally deciding to “capture all future positive earnings at the GSEs” — in fact, the law specifies otherwise. And the government’s own economists acknowledged future quarterly losses were highly unlikely.
Another document suggested announcing the change on Friday after markets had closed. “Rationale: GSE’s will report very strong earnings on August 7, that will be in-excess of the 10% dividend to paid to Treasury.” In other words, wait till late on an August Friday night — a media dead zone almost the equivalent of Christmas – to say that, even though the GSEs reported “very strong earnings” earlier in the week, it needed these prudent protections.
The documents released last week were made public only after years of government protest. The government has tried to keep 77,000 related documents from being released publicly and 11,000 from being shared even with attorneys for Fairholme.
The government’s out in this always was to claim that “since we intend to wind down the GSEs over time, the GSEs do not need to retain income in excess of amounts required to pay the 10 percent dividend,” which by making the government the largest investor with preferred stock, meant the money went to the Treasury and not the initial investors, such as Fairholme.
But the administration never offered a plan to wind down the GSEs, and the proposal would make little sense at this point.
What happened here is not hard to discern. The Obama administration had a convenient boogey man in the GSEs and a need for cash because of a recalcitrant Congress. It did not take into account the legal rights of the investors. The courts are slowly coming to this conclusion.
In the meantime, we’re left with another abuse of the public trust by double-dealing government insiders. If that’s not an argument for limited government, what is?
President Obama never was shy about using his phone and pen to achieve what he could not get from Congress on regulatory matters.
But documents revealed last week show the Obama administration may have been willing to get around congressional decisions on spending by using a slush fund of sorts funded by the profits of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, the two government-sponsored home loan giants.
Fannie and Freddie are federally chartered enterprises which buy mortgage loans from banks and bundle them into securities that are sold to investors, thus freeing up capital so that banks can make more home loans.
They are government-sponsored enterprises, which means the government guarantees their loans. But they are run as private enterprises, with private leadership, a board of directors and, most significantly for this purpose, investors. They’re even listed on the stock market.
In response to the mortgage crisis of 2008, Congress passed the Housing and Economic Recovery Act, which provided $187.5 billion in government loans for Fannie and Freddie and placed them in conservatorship under the newly established Federal Housing Finance Agency.
But Fannie and Freddie were not in such bad shape after all, and in just a few years, they were turning profits and on course to pay back the government with interest and still have money to pay dividends to their investors.
In 2012, the Obama administration came up with a plan to divert those profits to the Treasury that became known as the Net Worth Sweep. Officials said the profits had to be diverted back into the Treasury because Fannie and Freddie were in a “death spiral” and would have to return for loans, and this money would be used for those loans. In other words, Treasury would take all the profits from Fannie and Freddie and hold them for future loans when they again found themselves in trouble.
But — the administration knew Fannie and Freddie were healthy for the long term, were unlikely to need any more loans and, in fact, had enough money to pay dividends. The dividends were a problem for the administration because it made it hard to explain why it needed to abscond with Fannie and Freddie’s $241 billion in profits, execute an improper taking against the shareholders, and spend the money without congressional approval. Some even pushed to change accounting methods to make Fannie and Freddie look worse on paper and/or force them to “need” loans to survive.
In 2013, Fairholme Funds, one of those investors, filed suit, charging that, in sweeping the money back into the Treasury rather than pay dividends as required by law, the government exceeded its authority and ignored the law’s requirements that it conserve the assets of the enterprises. The government’s response indicates Fairholme’s accusations are probably dead on.
One of the documents released last week said the proposal to sweep the funds into Treasury would have “three primary benefits:”
It would “eliminate the circularity of Treasury funding the GSE’s dividends payments to Treasury.” It would “…capture all future earnings at the GSEs to help pay back taxpayers for their investment in those firms,” and it would “reduce future draws… so such draws would only be made when needed to fund quarterly net losses.”
The administration could have “eliminated the circularity” by following the law and paying the dividends. There is no legal basis for unilaterally deciding to “capture all future positive earnings at the GSEs” — in fact, the law specifies otherwise. And the government’s own economists acknowledged future quarterly losses were highly unlikely.
Another document suggested announcing the change on Friday after markets had closed. “Rationale: GSE’s will report very strong earnings on August 7, that will be in-excess of the 10% dividend to paid to Treasury.” In other words, wait till late on an August Friday night — a media dead zone almost the equivalent of Christmas – to say that, even though the GSEs reported “very strong earnings” earlier in the week, it needed these prudent protections.
The documents released last week were made public only after years of government protest. The government has tried to keep 77,000 related documents from being released publicly and 11,000 from being shared even with attorneys for Fairholme.
The government’s out in this always was to claim that “since we intend to wind down the GSEs over time, the GSEs do not need to retain income in excess of amounts required to pay the 10 percent dividend,” which by making the government the largest investor with preferred stock, meant the money went to the Treasury and not the initial investors, such as Fairholme.
But the administration never offered a plan to wind down the GSEs, and the proposal would make little sense at this point.
What happened here is not hard to discern. The Obama administration had a convenient boogey man in the GSEs and a need for cash because of a recalcitrant Congress. It did not take into account the legal rights of the investors. The courts are slowly coming to this conclusion.
In the meantime, we’re left with another abuse of the public trust by double-dealing government insiders. If that’s not an argument for limited government, what is?
About the Author: admin
Related posts
My ‘In This School of Life, We Learn’ Yard Sign
Bill Cosby sex assault case: 12 jurors chosen
DC sniper Lee Boyd Malvo's life sentence thrown out
Kentucky Coal Mining Museum switches to solar power
Qatar Charities Support of Extreme Islamist Ideology
What It's Like To Drive 300 MPH — From the Guy Who Did It…
Hilton flips out in court
Frankfurt First German City Where Natives Minority…
North Korea says it launched missile that can carry nuclear warhead – COMPLETE COVERAGE OF NORTH KOREA CRISIS
Wife of Texas church bus driver killed in crash found dead in home
DITCHING OBAMACARE Aetna to completely leave exchanges by 2018
'THE O'REILLY FACTOR': Sessions: Border crossing down because of Trump – 'TUCKER CARLSON TONIGHT': Tucker battles prof offended by airplane passenger giving seat to soldier – Drexel prof 'lives in a bubble,' Bin Laden's killer says
A Health Care Reform Compromise That Just Might Work
Trump: I 'need God even more' after becoming president
Woman dragged during carjacking at Massachusetts gas station, suspect at large, police say
Paul Krugman Explains Obamacare
DOWD: Sick to Your Stomach? #MeToo…
Obama, the Democratic disaster
'Dear Evan Hansen' wins big at Tonys
Lawmakers invited to view documents related to ex-national security adviser Flynn
So What's Going On with American Musical Theater?
US TO EXIT PARIS PACT Trump: US to leave climate agreement, calls it 'unfair'
British Airways passengers still facing long lines, cancellations after IT failure
How sharks can help the US Military in the future
Texas officer in viral hug says it 'meant the world to him'
WOMEN FILE SUIT CLAIMING ABUSE AT HAWAII PRISON…
Catholics and Muslims: Too Close for Comfort?
'DREAMERS' TURN ON PELOSI…
Can We Please Stop Pretending the NFL Protests Have Anything to Do with Free Speech?
'Not My President's Day' protests planned nationwide
Student loan debt up more than 450 percent since 2003
Megyn Kelly: 'I have no doubts' of sexual allegations against Ailes
Police: Calif. pastor stabbed to death by parishioner
Shakespearean Politics in Britain
Sanders' weapon against GOP entitlement reform: Trump
Clinton concedes to Trump
New Wave of Abuse Suits Could Hit Church Like Never Before…
NASA shows UFO on Mars
Former ambassador: Trump's 'ill-considered ban' may have inspired threats to US
Trump meets with victims of Ohio State terrorist attack
Ex-NYPD chief praises Trump's tougher immigrant vetting plans
Report: 13 boxes of Mike Pence's emails sent to Indiana Statehouse
'LET OBAMACARE EXPLODE' Trump blames Democrats as GOP pulls vote on doomed alternative
TODD STARNES: Sarah Huckabee Sanders called 'butch queen' by Daily Beast writer and the left is silent
Lynch zings Trump: 'I've always found facts to be of great help'
Media mock Trump's transition achievements
How mom lost 150 lbs
ATV tops all others
Trump's first foreign trip: Scheduled stops in Saudi Arabia, Israel and beyond – Who is King Salman of Saudi Arabia?
LIVE BLOG Comey on the Senate hot seat
'NOT CONCERNED' OVER KUSHNER Trump National Security Adviser says US involved with many back-channels
The media's anti-Trump sources talk so much and say so little
Putin's 'Marshall Plan' Aims to Contain NATO
Thorne flaunts short shorts
Wells Fargo Lost its Soul When It Quit the Iditarod
Trump communications pick accused of plagiarism
DHS estimates border wall may take $21 billion, over 3 years to build
Could North Korea Destroy the US?
Pennsylvania lawmakers to vote on future of 'ghost teachers'
'Teacher of the Year' gave student oral sex in classroom…
Texas father who forced daughter into prostitution is sentenced
'FOX & FRIENDS': Climate change protesters carve message on Trump golf course green
Trump takes control, gets his way on spending bill
‘Insects’ battle terrorism
MIDDLE EAST 'ATROCITY' Watchdog: Sarin used in April attack on Syrian town
Bernie Sanders: Dem leadership 'has failed'
PARIS ON EDGE Man shot dead trying to take soldier's weapon; French airport evacuated
World's once most obese man readies to undergo surgery in Mexico
Trump weighing visit to FBI headquarters
POWER GRAB? Turkey leader claims new authority after narrow vote
Former DNC chair blasts Jill Stein's 'waste of time' recount push
'Religious left' emerging as political force…
Press fumes as Trump breaks tradition
Truth in France on Past Persecution of Jews
Inside Organizing Effort Powering Mayor Pete's Iowa Surge…
Poll: 49 percent support Trump's immigration ban, 41 percent oppose
Community mourns Army veteran’s son whose bucket list went viral
Republicans keep the House, GOP looks to speaker's race
Report: Obama officials spent final days purposely pushing Russia allegations
Help to spot fake news
Woman contracts flesh-eating bacteria while fishing
Now, We Know My Mother Has Flaws, But…
Disgraced YOUTUBEr goes into meltdown in bizarre video…
Democrats Harris, Kennedy dismiss talk of challenging Trump in 2020
DEADLY TEXAS TWISTERS 5 dead, dozens injured as tornadoes decimate state
Germany and Islam
'Ghostbusters II' twin actor who played baby Oscar commits suicide
Warren Buffett: Today's babies are the 'luckiest crop in history'
2 Dead on Tom Cruise Movie Shoot…
University of Virginia to remove Confederate plaques, ban open flames – Which Confederate statues were removed? A running list
Documents: Russian interests paid Flynn $67G
Blagojevich daughter goes emo on Obama
Trump, Huntington Ingalls CEO discussed how to build carriers 'smarter' during shipyard visit
Mike Lee, Ben Sasse call on Trump to fire consumer bureau chief
Susan Sarandon: Pruitt is 'the end of the EPA'
'Shocking' spike of HPV-related cancer in young men worries researchers…
HARVARD hosts 'Anal Sex 101,' 'Oral Sex 101' and 'fatphobia' workshops…
MEDIA BUZZ: No evidence of Trump 'collusion' with Russia as media shift focus – Carter Page rips Obama-era 'surveillance,' wants to testify in public
The Trump Tax Cuts and the Obamacare Mandate 'Repeal'
End Bible classes? West Virginia school seeks to dismiss atheist lawsuit
US to conduct flight test of ballistic missile defense system
Comey's Game (II): The Mueller Gambit
Australian man who brutally attacked two backpackers sentenced to 22 years in prison
Model: I'm 'used to' stripping
Cotton, Purdue offer details of bill to cut legal immigration by 50 percent
Watch: Giuliani roasts de Blasio for eating pizza with a fork
Turkey's referendum campaign unfair, Erdogan opponents say
Former Trump banker Dies by Suicide in Malibu…
INSULT TO A HERO? Memo claims Glenn’s remains disrespected
300 companies, Carrier prod Senate to support Trump's energy nominee
These 60 DC restaurants will close for 'Day Without Immigrants' Thursday
Dads going under knife
Kim: I knew it was wrong
Shred the Veil
DID SHE KNOW? Jury will decide if Pulse killer’s wife played role
Jerry Falwell Jr. vying for education role in Trump administration
At least 4 dead after train derails in Greece
America's embarrassingly low economic freedom ranking
McConnell signals caution on Trump infrastructure bill
Katy went to Jesus camps
Couple charged after toddler dies from trauma from 'wrestling moves,' police say
Fidget spinners highlight unsafe toys report
Democrat says McConnell fired up activists by silencing Warren
Terrorists Don't Act Alone
Get ready for Pope Francis to make a video appearance at the Super Bowl
Zuckerberg again rejects claims of Facebook impact on U.S. election
The Left's Vicious Intolerance in Science
Religious leaders get high on magic mushrooms — for science…
10 days after election, the race for NC governor still undecided
Tom Cotton suggests ordering sergeant at arms to force Dems to vote on nominations
AMSTERDAM CAR CRASH 8 injured when driver hits pedestrians by train depot
Scope of Mexican sewage spill remains mystery, investigators say
Trump again insists Mexico will pay for wall…
LONDON ON EDGE: One arrested after van plows into crowd outside mosque, injuring 10 and stoking fears
California's Bogus 'Renewable Energy'
Journalists Pursue New Kind of Expose: Uncovering Their Salaries…
Graham: Senate silencing of Warren was 'long overdue'
Connect with God on vacation
Republicans may be mulling pre-inaugural repeal of Obamacare
A Pervasive Failure of Nerve in Higher Education
Man To Ride Out — On Boat…
Cory Booker's testimony looks a lot like a 2020 campaign kickoff
Yates reportedly to testify she warned White House about Flynn's Russia contacts
Anger over Las Vegas ban on sleeping in streets…
Assange may soon die in jail, father warns…
Fox News named in lawsuit by contributor over retracted Seth Rich story
Trump, Baldwin trade jabs after latest 'SNL' skit
Klobuchar on Bloomberg bid: We don't need anyone telling us 'we aren't enough'…
Comey Fired — Now Indict Hillary
Asymmetric Information in the Age of Trump
Cutting the Obamacare Knots
Jeff Sessions and the Conservative Talkers
The Embarrassing, Hilarious, Can't-Look-Away Trudeau Show
Mom's pic goes viral
Leo making lifestyle change
How the RNC mobilized military veterans to produce record support for Trump
Trump team mulls national infrastructure bank
HE'S BACK! Sessions announces Alabama Senate bid…
An American Oligarchy vs. We the People
WALMART apologizes for sweater featuring Santa with cocaine…
Priebus says Trump administration considered changes to libel laws
AMAZON mulls face-scanning doorbells…
Trump beats Obama engagement with Congress, say friend and foe
Jelly Belly sued
MARK ZUCKERBERG CRUSHING SLIDING SNAPCHAT…
When camping disaster strikes
FACE OF HATE Radical cleric tied to UK terror attacks
GULF RIFT DEEPENS Tillerson urges calm after four sever ties with Qatar
Replica of lunar module stolen from Neil Armstrong museum
Guns Don’t Kill People; Liberalism and Radical Islam Do
'Angel Baby' singer Rose Hamlin dies at 71
'Big Wake-up Call': 'Giant UFO' Over California Seen 'by More Than 100 Witnesses'…
Fort Lauderdale gunman could face death penalty
Declaring War on Trump's Truthful Tweets
Source of Georgia street drug that killed as many as 4 people still unknown
Reimagining the Democratic Party
Princeton asks students to pick from six 'genders'
House Republicans test Trump on his U.S.-Mexico wall
ESPN’S BAD CALL Website posted poem honoring fugitive cop killer
A Tale of Three Cities
RUDY IN THE SHADOWS
Trump tells Jewish reporter to sit down and be quiet after question about rising anti-Semitism
Second Amendment case Peruta vs. California may be heading to Supreme Court – Supreme Court rejects appeal to reinstate North Carolina voter ID law
Report: Paul Ryan delays committee assignments until January
Good Jobs Are Out There – It’s the Schools that Are Failing
'Not My President' rallies dishonor Presidents Day
Brandenburg Barack Reprimands Donald Trump
'HANNITY' Dr. Ben Carson describes agenda as HUD secretary
If Immigration Creates Wealth, Why Is California America's Poverty Capital?
California girl dies during dental procedure, family says
Mom paralyzed after eating gas station nacho cheese
Secret to crispy chicken skin
A Time for War: Deep State's Strike and Trump's Counter-Strike
Mexico Journalists Fear Hostile Turn Under President…
Intel officials: CIA can't explain why Russia hacked Dems
Military bases increase security after shootings in Hawaii, Florida…
Parents of girl found dead in garage charged in Illinois
Afghan wounded warriors compete for spot in Invictus Games
The New Struggle: Religion, Morality, and American Law
Trump plans to cut EPA staff in half
Marco Rubio and his wife to have dinner with Trumps
Ancient Aztec temple uncovered
Alabama officials: 2 teens, 2 adults killed in plane crash
Gunmen storm Quebec City mosque, kill multiple people
GOP sees Haley as a chance for UN reform
Noose found inside Smithsonian's African-American history museum
VIDEO: TESLA Drivers Wait Hour to Charge Vehicles…
Trump Trolling the Media, Winning the Narrative
CA Wet Winter Causes Lettuce Shortage; Prices Double…
'BEAUTIFUL LITTLE GIRL' 8-year-old among first victims ID'd in UK bombing
2020 VISION Obama-tied group's census contract raises questions
UPDATE: BRAZIL MEAT SCANDAL DEEPENS AS CHINA, EU, CHILE BAR IMPORTS…
Crayola set to retire one color from crayon box
TRUMP TAPS TILLERSON Secretary of state tasked with fixing Russia relations
John F Kennedy's life and legacy remembered on 35th president's 100th birthday
Dick Durbin: Race-Baiting Hypocrite
'Parasite singles': Why young Japanese aren't getting married…
Rep. Barton tells man to 'shut up' at heated town hall
Are PBS and Ken Burns about to Rewrite History Again?
How the FAA Hinders Innovation
ESPN makes another cut
Campbell says 'Adios'
PATRIOTS JOLTED BY HOME GAME LOSS…
TIGER'S TROUBLES Police: Woods impaired; passed Breathalyzer
Colorado teen dies after falling from roof of school building during game
Civil rights groups decry Sessions confirmation: 'Corruption of values we hold dear'
Kansas, Georgia takeaway: Special elections results mixed in predicting future
Miami police officer fines Uber driver for violating ordinance requiring ability to speak English
Conway on Trump transition: 'Loyalty is very important to him'
Reality show villain Omarosa joins the Trump White House
AMAZON critics mark Cyber Monday with rally at Bezos penthouse……
Joe Biden leaves 'proof' of time served as vice president
Trump: 'I haven't called Russia in 10 years'
Who Is Obama?
The New Terrorist-Industrial Complex
Obama's final message to the country: 'I'm still asking you to believe'
EU leaders mark bloc's 60th anniversary
Soldier gets airline ticket home, thanks to a stranger
Feds say suspect in Chinese scholar's disappearance visited bondage website
MEDIA BUZZ: Why the press hate Trump's climate deal exit – FOX BIZ OPINION: Paris climate deal was another bad move by Obama
FAMILY PLOT? Manchester bomber's father, brother nabbed as more terror ties revealed
Give the GOP a Break: Draining the Swamp Is Hard
Why Don't We Turn Populist?
Afghanistan funeral explosions turn deadly
ObamaCare problems deepen, as Senate bill sidelined – VIDEO: Obamacare: Co-ops, premiums worry consumers
Dianne Feinstein's Mind-Boggling Decision
How Much Should Taxpayers Invest in Elon Musk?
Musk's New Test: Keep Mouth in Check at 'Pedo Guy' Trial…
Trump likely to reward loyalty with top appointments
'Sick:' Trump slams report of 'second meeting' with Putin at G-20 summit – Tucker battles Dem: 'Not every person with Cyrillic letters in their name is working for Putin'
Sweden (Still) Resists the Right
Scorching the Earth
FOX NEWS EXCLUSIVE Photos show devastation of Mother of All Bombs in Afghanistan
EASTWOOD'S 'RICHARD JEWELL' FACES BOYCOTT OVER 'SEXIST' DEPICTION OF REPORTER…
Pratt 'hurt' by fan comments

EXCLUSIVE: 'Foreign infiltration' feared amid 'security risks' in Pentagon immigrant recruit program
Israel demands explanation from White House after spat over Trump trip
EX-PRISONER'S PAYDAY Former Gitmo detainee to get millions from Canada
North Korea fires another projectile into the Sea of Japan – North Korea test-fires new anti-aircraft weapon system – COMPLETE COVERAGE OF THE CRISIS OVER NORTH KOREA
VIOLENCE IN OREGON Pro-Trump, anti-Trump rallies converge in Portland
