
The Republicans’ moment of victory on health care didn’t last long.
With cancer-stricken John McCain making a stirring speech and casting the decisive procedural vote on Tuesday, President Trump and Mitch McConnell were able to get the health bill out of intensive care and to the Senate floor.
But in the vote hours later on the main repeal-and-replace bill—the one that the president and GOP leadership have been pushing so hard—nine Republican senators defected. It wasn’t even close.
In other words, the president’s team is no closer to getting a health care bill than before McConnell, with an appeal to party loyalty, miraculously brought the effort back from the dead. The Republican divide is as deep as ever.
Indeed, the Republicans failed again yesterday to pass a repeal-only bill, which Trump favored as a backup but which never had a chance.
Their only hope now is to pass something fairly miniscule and declare victory.
But the so-called “skinny repeal” is looking increasingly like anorexic repeal.
Keep in mind that Republicans spent seven years promising to repeal and replace ObamaCare. It’s awfully hard for them to walk away empty-handed.
So they need to pass something, anything, to get to a House-Senate conference and then declare victory.
Given that this fight has consumed the first six months of the administration, my sense is that the GOP would like to rid itself of the issue and move on. HHS Secretary Tom Price actually spoke on CNBC of passing “the lowest common denominator…What gets us to 50 votes so that we can move forward on a health-care reform legislation… that’s what needs to happen.”
The skinny repeal, as I understand it, would abolish the Obama law’s mandates for individuals and larger companies (and ax a tax on medical device makers).
One problem is that without a mandate, lots of healthy people can just wait till they get sick to buy insurance, which could shatter the financial underpinnings of the system. The larger dilemma is that this would leave almost all of ObamaCare in place, including subsidies, regulations on required services and the Medicaid expansion.
One other thought: there has not been a single committee hearing on this legislation that affects one-sixth of the economy.
As McCain said before voting to proceed (and later supporting the repeal-and-replace bill): “We’ve tried to do this by coming up with a proposal behind closed doors in consultation with the administration, then springing it on skeptical members, trying to convince them it’s better than nothing, asking us to swallow our doubts and force it past a unified opposition. I don’t think that’s going to work in the end, and it probably shouldn’t.”
If Democrats were doing that, the right would be going crazy. The Dems did use parliamentary maneuvers to ram through ObamaCare on a party-line vote, but they held lots of hearings.
McConnell has no time to worry about legislative niceties. After the Republican defections on the bigger bills, he’s got an uphill battle to get to 50—on something.
Howard Kurtz is a Fox News analyst and the host of “MediaBuzz” (Sundays 11 a.m.). He is the author of five books and is based in Washington. Follow him at @HowardKurtz. Click here for more information on Howard Kurtz.
About the Author: admin
Related posts
AHCA cuts $1 trillion in ObamaCare taxes – Republican health care bill headed for overhaul in Senate – Sanders mocks Trump’s praise for Australian healthcare – VIDEO: Hollywood celebs attack Trump over AHCA
Ashton on cheating rumors
DOJ expresses 'grave concerns' over Baltimore police deal with Obama administration
Brian Williams: Fake news swayed the election
Trump: 'I haven't called Russia in 10 years'
Uber bans woman for life for purportedly threatening to accuse driver of rape
Alien ships near Saturn?
July 4th and Freedom of Speech
Political leaders tweet Independence Day messages – NC town cancels July 4 celebrations after threats
NEWT GINGRICH Democrats turn to red tape to stop President Trump
Armed man arrested at DC restaurant that was center of Clinton conspiracy theory
Syrian military: Aleppo has returned to government control
Obama 'stands by' his Trump insults
Ramsay’s latest kitchen victim
Nigel Farage: 'Political revolution' in UK, USA is headed to Austria
Tropical Storm Cindy causes minor flooding across South as rain continues
Trump supporter shouts profanities at Chicago 'Hamilton' performance
'IT WAS AMATEUR HOUR' Jimmy John's clerk recalls intense armed robbery
Jimmy Kimmel: 'We have no tolerance for fake news' at the Oscars
What Message Can Be Gleaned from Contradictory Ideas?
What's a 'Pill Cosby'?
Trump signs executive orders authorizing Keystone XL, Dakota Access pipelines
'WE'RE NOT WINNING' Sheriff's stance on life-saving drug questioned
Trump announces White House policy team
End Judicial Tyranny with One Single Word
Death of New York state judge found in Hudson River reportedly 'suspicious'
Dog finds Michigan family's missing cat under house fire rubble
INFLUENTIAL MEETING? Saudi names new heir months after Trump trip
Philippines declares 8-hour cease-fire in besieged city
How much is safe to drink?
Things Your Professor Didn’t Tell You About Climate Change
Students stage global climate protests to pressure UN summit…
Al Gore claim about Hurricane Florence doused by scientists…
Breitbart editor Milo Yiannopoulos appears to defend pedophilia
Election over, Congress pivots to lame-duck debate over spending
Democrats: 'Let's Do the Time Warp Again'
Florida man who tried to hack Clinton Foundation avoids additional jail time
Schumer, McConnell elected top leaders in U.S. Senate
Amy's special a huge flop?
200-pound bomb…
'WE HIT A HOME RUN' Trump touts successes of first foreign trip in speech
Sen. Cory Booker: 'God bless' the Trump protesters
2020 hopeful McAuliffe to Mexico to promote trade…
GOLDEN STATE GROWS USGS says California is now 13 acres bigger
Nicole Richie gets slapped
Trump faces two deadlines as Congress ramps up impeachment focus…
Machiavelli's Advice for Mr. Trump – and Us
Uber CEO takes indefinite leave, top executives will run company – Uber Holder report: 3 things to know
ObamaCare vote do-over? House could be forced to revisit bill – Trump budget to cut Medicaid, food stamps — put 'taxpayer first,' officials say
Defeating Iran's Mullahs
Emerging from obscurity: 2019's unforeseen history-makers…
After the wall, GOP unclear on Trump's immigration plans
Hacker apparently leaks stolen episodes of Netflix series
Is Silicon Valley Dynasty Coming to End?
California bans state travel to Texas, 3 other states over anti-LGBT laws
The Great Hurricane Absence
GREG GUTFELD How to explain Trump to your liberal friends
Adam West, TV's 'Batman,' dies at 88 after leukemia battle: family – VIDEO: 'Batman' star Adam West dead at age 88
Radio host Ingraham says she's being considered for White House post
America's embarrassingly low economic freedom ranking
Trump won't fill hundreds of administration jobs
Iran says it arrested eight with CIA links during unrest…
Wyoming police get big surprise after panhandler Facebook post
Lights up CA sky…
Paris IMF letter bomb: Possible link to failed German bomb investigated – France high school shooting: Armed teen arrested, 10 hurt
Pope warns the powerful in surprise TED talk
China's War Timing Firming Up
Christopher 'Big Black' Boykin, star of MTV's 'Rob & Big,' dies at 45
Navy sailor whose conviction Trump said was overkill is denied pardon – USS Fitzgerald crash: Navy holds memorial to seven sailors killed
Swexit? Swedish politician says his country will be next to ditch European Union
Kim goes off on Scott
Blagojevich daughter goes emo on Obama
Trump pledges $50M to help women entrepreneurs
Trump's doctor: 'If something happens to him, then it happens to him'
Dems frustrated but powerless to stop Trump's HHS pick
NEW GETAWAY Trump visits 'rustic' Camp David for the first time
SCHULTZ: Election spoiler is far-left…
Students give Watters 'astounding' answers to citizenship test questions
Man charged with abuse after allegedly locking 2 children in trash container – Toddler dies after car window closes on his neck
BREAKING NEWS Key House Republican Steve Scalise, aides shot in Virginia
Veterans Affairs official mocking Trump over Twitter
Alleged iPhone thieves take selfies posted onto owner's iCloud
TODD STARNES: Hey, Sean Spicer, I was attacked by a raging feminist, too – Trump wants press corps to pick where to donate his salary, Spicer says
Netanyahu vows to defy United Nations over Israel settlements resolution
BELLWETHER The national security battle the media isn't discussing
Soldier killed by explosive device is third US combat death this week in Iraq and Afghanistan
In the Franken Scandal, Be Careful What You Wish For
High Court allows strict enforcement of Trump ban – Trump travel ban: Timeline of a legal journey
Trump congratulates senior aide Miller on Sunday show performance
Brave father stops shooter during Father's Day dinner at Florida restaurant – Myrtle Beach shooting captured on Facebook Live injures 6, suspect nabbed
Pit bull mauls 6-month-old baby to death in Nevada
House intel chief: 'Unacceptable' intel officials not cooperating in Russia probe
Chicago judge killed: FBI offers $25G reward for info
Dozens in Ga. forced to evacuate as wildfire spreads
Reporters Sleep as 60 Black People Rob a BART Train in Oakland
COMEY UNLEASHED: Ex-FBI boss accuses Team Trump of 'lies,' suggests Lynch covered for Clinton
Trump protesters hold 'mock funeral' for the presidency
Anthony Scaramucci's wife files for divorce, report says
A Preview of Liberalism’s End Point
McConnell signals caution on Trump infrastructure bill
Twitter creator laments role of social media in election of Trump
Chaos at UCLA…
T-Mobile and Leftism
Supreme Court filibuster: The Left demands Democrats block Gorsuch
His Name Was Scout
BEZOS A 'DIFFERENT SPECIES'…
Donald J. Trump sworn in as the 45th president, vows 'we will get the job done'
‘Why I contour my boobs’
Everything (That's Not Sexism) Is Racism
Documents: Russian interests paid Flynn $67G
NASA MISSION TO 'TOUCH SUN'…
MSNBC fires Greta Van Susteren, replaces her with liberal host
Media swing back at Trump in fight over inauguration crowd size
Nate Silver: Clinton 'almost certainly' would be president if not for Comey
Ancient Rome's lesson as impeachment inquiry progresses…
London Update: West to Blame for Islamic Terrorism
Trump fires back at Carrier union boss: He's done a 'terrible' job
Have Repeal Efforts Always Been a Republican Ruse?
Infant boy fatally shot while in father's arms in Houston
Tariffs Won't Help Make America Great Again
Parents of girl found dead in garage charged in Illinois
Video shows patron take on robber at California Starbucks
BIDEN INSTITUTE University launches ex-VP research and policy center
Multiple Women Recall Sex Misconduct, Retaliation by Amb. Sondland…
Trump Can Win More by Tweeting Less
CALL TO ARMS Sen. Graham wants up to 6,000 more troops in Syria
McConnell: Democrats using double standard on Gorsuch
ISIS reportedly releases first message targeting Trump – ISIS turns Mosul museum into tax office
KILL ZONE: Car bomb kills at least 80, wounds hundreds inside Afghan capital's diplomatic ring
Will the Swamp Drain Trump?
Miami man arrested in botched butt lift procedure
Tourists Ruined Venice. Now Floods Making It Uninhabitable…
COLBERT UNDER FIRE Calls to ax host grow over gay slur against Trump
Trump strikes back, asks 'Hamilton' cast to apologize to Mike Pence
Border agents discover 67 pounds of marijuana in casket at checkpoint
Biden's message to Trump: Grow up, stop tweeting
Delaware trooper shot outside Wawa dies; suspect surrounded in home – Georgia deputy shot, manhunt underway near outlet mall
Ex-employee warns of 'disturbing' plans…
New Arizona Development Bans Residents From Bringing Cars…
Humans have 100 years left
Coulter, immigration hawks already worried Trump going soft
Trump's VA pick draws mixed reactions
US service member dies Thanksgiving Day in Syria
Sticky trial questions: How long? Who testifies?
Pirates return to Somalia waters, US officials say
Benghazi mastermind's FBI statements should be dismissed, lawyers say
Trump to reveal new information about hacking of Democrats

'WE WILL TAKE SPECIFIC ACTION' Japan vows to work with US to respond to latest N. Korea missile test
John Cornyn: Obamacare replacement will cover just as many people
Fighting Anti-Israeli Bias at the UN
Israel President: Climate of Vicious Hatred Could Spark Assassination…
Napoleon Dynamite? Watters quizzes Jersey beachgoers on Bastille Day
'Hillary for Prison' sign spotted at Trump rally
Massive statue of Egyptian ruler discovered in Cairo
Hillary Clinton blames Comey, WikiLeaks and 'misogyny' for 2016 loss
Carter Page was the Camel's Nose in Trump's Tent
VIDEO: Nation's Oldest High School Rivalry Ends With Massive Brawl…
In Search of Justice in France
The Democrats as Russian Dupes, 2018 Edition
Istanbul Trans Pride march to go on despite govt ban
Protectionist profiteer Wilbur Ross Would Make America China Again
Obama underestimated Islamic State: 'Not on my intelligence radar screen'
Obama: 'I'll examine it when it comes' if I need to speak out during Trump's presidency
Help Wanted: Women as Recruiters for ISIS
Imposing Sanctions on Venezuela Will Only Make Things Worse
'LET OBAMACARE EXPLODE' Trump blames Democrats as GOP pulls vote on doomed alternative
Why Republicans can't just pass a big tax cut instead of an overhaul
Cosmonaut shows space station hole to calm public…
San Bernardino terror attack victims still fighting to get proper treatment
Gingrich praises Trump's vow to expand US nukes
Soros battles $10B lawsuit, familiar charges of wielding political influence – WATCH: 'I have a message for you': PA governor candidate slams George Soros
Report: Obama officials spent final days purposely pushing Russia allegations
Cops say hands are tied in arresting unruly 'desnudas' naked female panhandlers 'because most are illegal immigrants'
Trump: Oscars 'focused so hard on politics' they messed up award show
What do your sex dreams mean?
The Rule of Law, Blowing in the Wind like a MAGA Hat
World's LARGEST plane unveiled
TRUMP'S BRIGHT IDEA? President talks up 'solar wall' option for the border
Stalking an Active Shooter
The Underreported Success of the Trump Presidency
Trump: The Unlikeliest Churchillian
After Harvey and Al and Charlie, the Left Still Does Not Get It
EXCLUSIVE Rosenstein pressed on re-opening Clinton probe
Mark Steyn: Special counsel investigation is 'banana republic stuff'
Trump Navy secretary pick Philip Bilden withdraws from consideration
Ellison: 'What if we started talking to everybody?'
Issa clings to narrow lead in last undecided House race
North Carolina motorists who hit protesters blocking roadways will be legally protected under proposed bill
Needing Eden
Calif. AG seeks to reinstate charges against pro-life activists over secret tapes
Guilfoyle blasts De Blasio for being OK with PR day parade honoring terrorist
Boeing CEO says he'll build Air Force Ones for less than $4 billion after Trump meeting
A Spectator’s Guide to the Gorsuch Hearings
Trump's Energy Success
A Professor Looks at the College Racket
SLAVE TO THE ALGORITHM: AMAZON PUSHES TO BRINK…
Trump considering Rep. Hensarling for Treasury secretary: WSJ
Living with Anti-Semitism in America
Kate Upton sizzles for July 4
Leftists and Islamists: Strange Bedfellows
America's most popular dog for 2016 revealed
Model done with Leo
Expert Views: What will be the impact of Trump presidency on immigration, refugees?
Educating Colleges: Free Speech Isn't Free
Our President Is a Street Fighter
Senate Republicans ask Trump to arm Ukrainians, maintain Russia sanctions
Why School Choice Will Continue to Grow in Popularity
Fingerspitzengefuhl: What It Is and Why We Need It
Democrats: The Party of the Super-Duper (Mostly White) Gazillionaires
Man 'assaulted' with cash
Trump: US showed Israel 'total disdain and disrespect'
Confronting Leftist Lies
Driver arrested at US/Mexico border after 4 Chinese immigrants found stuffed in trunk
Widow of Apple's Steve Jobs buys Atlantic magazine
Interstate mess: Atlanta roadwork leads to buckling on I-20
How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love The Donald
Justice Kennedy wants more 'inspiring' public discourse
