
Very often people who don’t like your ideas, or maybe fear that you are right, will try to pull this trick on you. They will try to place you in “the prison of two ideas.”
They set up an issue as having only two positions — you’re either for or against “X” — and then place you on the side that sounds most evil.
For example, a person might say:
— You’re either for climate change legislation, or you want the planet to die
— You’re either for ObamaCare, or you want babies and sick people to die
— You’re either for peace, or you want war
— You’re either for amnesty, or you’re xenophobic
It’s painful and predictable. Verging on parody. But sometimes we do the same to our adversaries, too.
— Either you’re for the death penalty or you coddle criminals
— Either you’re pro-gun, or a leftwing socialist gun grabber
— Either you fear God, or are a godless pinko
The right does this sort of thing less often, but maybe it’s because we’ve had less practice.
But we also allow ourselves to become inmates in our own two-idea prison — by appointing “an idea warden.”
This takes the shape of a political leader whose ideas become reflexively accepted as our ideas. Through a subtle submission to authoritarian allure, we end up settling on the side of an argument because he or she holds that side, too.
It’s political team sport stuff.
And so if he decides that X is bad, you agree. If he believes we need less of Y, you do, too. But if he changes his mind, realizing that X is good, and Y is a necessity, then you change with him as well.
This “idea warden” gives you the freedom to ignore any alternative ideas because you’ve put all your eggs in his basket — whether that basket be trade, immigration or taxes.
The interesting discovery, with President Donald Trump, is because his positions change, he happily demolishes the prison of two ideas, while still being a prison warden for so many others. It’s brilliant, but troubling.
So, I’m thinking, Instead of agreeing with Donald Trump, we should be copying him. As he divorces himself from the prison of two ideas, we should too.
President Trump, through his actions on trade, China, Syria, Russia, and ObamaCare – reveals that between two opposing ideas there’s an endless number of options. Literally — the positions one can hold are infinite.
Trump’s view of things has more choices than the order of cards in a typical deck. I really believe this. In a deck, there are 52 cards — which means the total possible combinations would be (yes, I read this on a blog): 80,658,175,170,943,878,571,660,636,856,403,766,975,289,505,440,883,277,824,000,000,000,000.
That’s more than the number of people (in billions) on every planet if there were a billion planets in 200 billion solar systems and so on (don’t ask me to verify this — it’s from Reddit).
Ponder this crazy, fantastic number. Because it frees you from sticking to two sides. It reminds you that you can think of anything.
How can you free yourself and think differently about things?
Consider one side, and work toward a compatible alternative that solves whatever accusation might be lobbed at you.
Take immigration. Are you xenophobic for wanting a wall?
No, you can be for enforced, enhanced border protection, while welcoming grateful refugees and hard-working immigrants. You can be for that wall, and that giant beautiful door. You see: Trump used a simple sentence to destroy the prison of two ideas. People remember the wall, but he also offered the door.
Climate change: So, are you accepting the “consensus,” or do you want the planet to die, you anti-science heathen?
Your answer destroys that two idea prison: You remain open to that idea that there has been gradual warming over time — and that humans might contribute to it (which is where the consensus claim tentatively rests) — and will even worry that it could be a problem.
However, the solutions prescribed by the most vocal and spot-lit climate activists are extreme and unreliable. The climate models and predictions have been notoriously inaccurate (comically so), and the claims too variable.
Last, the money one demands to fight this threat might actually do harm by steering funds away from efforts that might actually save millions of lives right now (in terms of promoting and pursuing clean air, water, fuel, etc). Describe yourself as a “luke-warmer.”
Health care: Your angry liberal friend might say, “you’re either for ObamaCare or you want people to die on the streets.” (I wish I were creating a straw man argument here, but this is an actual refrain.)
To destroy this two idea prison, offer the simplest solution: We want everyone to be healthy, and to be able to afford health care when really bad stuff happens. So it’s not about birth control pills (which even college kids can afford).
The most practical answer is that we, the consumer, pay for the small stuff, and insurance covers the rest. Suddenly catastrophic insurance becomes hugely affordable. Take a page from car insurance (which, by the way, isn’t “car care,” it’s car insurance). There’s variability in coverage and cost, based on individual needs and types. There is also competition (compare the number of car insurance ads to the number of health insurance ads during your favorite cable news show). Competition, in every arena, puts the customer first (in this case: the patient).
The most important arena where the two idea prison must be destroyed: National security.
If you wish to fight terror with every weapon at your disposal — well, then you must be Islamophobic. That’s the new prison of two ideas: worrying about terror means you’re a bigot.
To shatter this prison, one must only point out the reality of the current age: technology married to terror means our defenses merit a different mindset. We aren’t fighting traditional wars any more. We now must consider that a drone carrying a toxic substance, tested in one country — can now be unleashed here in this country by a satellite jihadists, over a parade or a stadium — killing tens of thousands, or more. And that satellite jihadist may be an American citizen! So how is that racist? Or bigoted?
The simpler point: You can be against invading countries, but you can recognize threats far away, that intend to come here.
So, in sum: The prison of two ideas is less your choice than it is one made by political adversaries to beat you at debate.
Once you break out of it, the possibilities for winning become endless.
Greg Gutfeld currently serves as host of FOX News Channel’s (FNC) The Greg Gutfeld Show (Saturdays 10-11PM/ET) and co-host of The Five (weekdays 9-10PM/ET). He joined the network in 2007 as a contributor. Click here for more information on Greg Gutfeld.
About the Author: admin
Related posts
French Election: Commission probes Macron hacking as voters prepare to have their say
Russian Hacking and Collusion: Put the Cards on the Table
Subverting the Electoral Process
Ivanka Trump will have difficulty pushing father to left on environment
Trump attacks the cast of 'Hamilton' after Mike Pence incident
Union outraged after NWA's 'F— Tha Police' sung to dining officers
Mississippi recruits homegrown doctors to cure shortage
House GOP passes $788B bill for Pentagon, border wall – Eboni Williams: Sanctuary cities endanger the immigrant community – Men charged with ICE agent's 2011 killing found guilty
Veteran bares all for ESPN
SENATE SHOWDOWN Will GOP go 'nuclear' to confirm Judge Gorsuch?
Man defends wife's parenting
Donald Trump's Crimes
In his hometown, Democrats respect Hardiman's 'principled' conservatism
The Anti-Christian Movement
Otto Warmbier’s injuries renew focus on North Korea’s infamous torture camps
Report: Kushner is under FBI scrutiny
TABLES TURNED? Alex Jones releases tapes before Megyn Kelly chat
Las Vegas officials rethink bus security, ads after shooting
USA releases $100M military assistance to 'Lebanon after months of unexplained delay'…
ONE STEP CLOSER Border wall models set to be rolled out in summer
Exit sparks scramble for big-money donors…
Fire destroys Boston-area apartment complex under construction
China Reveals Hypersonic Strike Aircraft…
Ten of thousands in U.S. cities to protest Trump's presidency
Cory Booker Is Sharpton, Not Spartacus
Minnesota man under arrest hands cop 'Get out of jail free' Monopoly card
MeToo unnerves China…
James Murdoch Denies Plans for Liberal News Site…
Air Force colonel sentenced for child porn
MAY DAY? PM looks to hang on as Brits weigh terror, Brexit
Reports: Russia's ambassador to Turkey shot in art gallery
Newt Gingrich warns of new threat underlying 'fake news'
NJ prosecutors no longer pursuing misconduct charge against Christie for 'Bridgegate'
Pulling the Plug on Health Care Reform
'What a wuss': CNN's Navarro blasts WH official's defense of Trump's WWE tweet – 'You're getting played': GOP Rep takes on CNN host over Trump tweets – Conway: Media obsesses over Trump's tweets & ignores his policies
Marine veteran who lost both legs in Afghanistan sworn in as NY police officer
Sen. Roy Moore?
QUIET ON THE BORDER Arrests plummet as DHS touts enforcement push
Time to Fight, Mr. President
Russian ambassador to UN Vitaly Churkin dies
Two Netanyahus Meet Two Trumps
GOP sinks $1 million into Obamacare repeal campaign
Justice Department to appeal judge's order to block Trump's travel ban
SECURITY FEARS HEIGHTENED Manchester terror attack ignites safety concerns ahead of summer
Trump wishes 'love,' happy New Year to his 'many enemies'
Rich, poor band together …
Nancy's 'DWTS' meltdown
Mattis: 'No doubt' Assad used chemical weapons against civilians – Tillerson in Moscow, getting in line with Haley on tough Syria talk – 'TUCKER CARLSON TONIGHT': Hopkins on ousting Assad — We 'need to choose our monsters'
So Where Are the Podesta Indictments?
Kansas, UCLA among teams moving to Sweet 16, Duke upset by South Carolina – Confederate flag flies near arena – NCAA MEN'S BASKETBALL TOURNEY BRACKET
Viral message about sizes
Military ops in Syria getting complicated for Washington…
A Cause for War?
Mental Health and Gun Control
82-Year-Old Bodybuilding Grandma Takes Down Burglar…
Hunter shoots down 820-pound wild hog in yard
Sen. Ben Sasse: US is 'in the midst of a civilization-warping crisis of public trust'
FEC commissioner: 'I will not be silenced' on Trump's voter fraud claims
'GOOD FAITH EFFORT' Durbin floats bipartisan deal to rework ObamaCare
RAPE OUTRAGE Parents sound off at fiery Maryland school meeting
GULF RIFT DEEPENS Tillerson urges calm after four sever ties with Qatar
Top US general affirms pledge to 'de-conflicting' operations in Syria with Russian counterpart
Jewish center bomb threats: Ex-journalist to plead guilty
'Born-again Christian' accused of trying to kidnap sex workers…
MYSTERY UNSOLVED? Comey testimony failed to cover anti-Trump dossier
Survey: Small businesses are hurting for credit access
We Cannot Be Great without God
Trump attacks 'fake news' amid Russia controversy that now includes Kushner
Galaxy S8 prices leaked?
Woman dragged during carjacking at Massachusetts gas station, suspect at large, police say
How Can We Stop School Shootings?
When should parents start saving for child's wedding day?
That time Sean Spicer (really) dressed as the White House Easter Bunny – McCarthy dresses like the Easter Bunny to pan Spicer's Hitler gaffe
Documentarian Set Out to Expose Monogamy as Sham. Then Fell in Love With Her Subject…
When to throw away wine
Dear Juanita Broaddrick
'PERFECT VICTIMS' Man convicted of rape attempt wrote of his plans
Ignorance and the Decline of Responsible Government in America
Morning Joe hosts attack Conway: 'She's not credible anymore'
Is Islam a Genocidal Religion?
STILL OUT THERE? 'King' polar bear findings could solve mystery to past
Trump still winner after Wisconsin recount, adds 162 votes to tally
Fire destroys 'squatter' home where 16-month-old girl found dead
EMTs, firefighters need guns, Texas lawmakers say
'Fixer Upper' big announcement
Nun’s death investigated
Health Moves to Center…
Dems mull focus on Midwest, South after election drubbing
Snubs, Surprises…
Anonymous donor pays off church's $4M mortgage
Hillary Clinton: Faust and Mephistopheles Rolled into One
Proposed shooting range with bar faces opposition from local residents
Palestinian fatally stabs 3 Israelis after deadly clashes near Jerusalem holy site
Senate passes Russia sanctions package
Arizona to stop using controversial drug after botched executions
Merkel arrives at Auschwitz for first time…
Insane 'Star Wars' bike trail
Tucker Carlson named Megyn Kelly's Fox News replacement
United passenger dragged off flight settles with airline for undisclosed amount – Delta passenger kicked off flight after using restroom
Carolinas bracing for next round of severe weather
Hillary Clinton surprises Katy Perry at Snowflake Ball
MANIAC UNMASKED: London police identify UK Parliament attacker
Media hysteria over Trump's possible changes to White House briefing
RNC to lead 'war room' to defend White House
Treasury's Mnuchin makes rare Canada visit amid tensions
9 teens wounded in hurt at California house party
ASSAD'S INSTASCAM Critics: Syria's 1st lady has social media ruse
'IT'S A BRUTAL REGIME' Trump slams North Korea after former American prisoner Otto Warmbier dies
House of Commons speaker moves to block Trump from addressing parliament
Secret Service investigating agent who wrote she wouldn't take 'a bullet' for Trump
Dems try populism…
Man shot dead at Florida charity car show after going after cop with knife, police say
Russian warships fire cruise missiles at Islamic State positions in Syria
Republican Ben Carson opts against job in Trump Cabinet
2016 was a good year for the defense industry, despite those Trump tweets
Pulse shooting survivor dies in Florida car crash, officials say
Why Trump is Right on Jerusalem
FIGHTING BACK: DOJ challenges Hawaii judge’s halt on new travel ban
Civil lawsuit over Michael Brown's death nears settlement with Ferguson
Trump: US 'has a lot of killers'
'I ain't serving no police': McDonald's employee refuses to serve uniformed police officer
Iran and Middle East Instability
US workforce dying faster than any other wealthy country…
Trump to return to Mar-a-Lago for third weekend in a row
When the Single Payer Becomes the Single Player
Dick Durbin: Race-Baiting Hypocrite
Woman on desperate search to find doctor who will operate on son with rare disease
Educating Colleges: Free Speech Isn't Free
Massachusetts boy called police to say dad had drugs in luggage
Steve Bannon celebrates 'hobbits,' 'deplorables' for electing Trump
Why mosquitoes are considered a worldwide threat
Dems worry about Ellison allegations as state AG race tightens…
GOP hangs 'Hire Pelosi' sign outside headquarters
BRINK OF NUCLEAR WAR? N. Korea: US bomber flight may cause major conflict
The people have chosen, damn them
American student stuck in China jail for days is freed, family says
Sexy shoes for cheap drinks
College football player gives up NCAA eligibility for YouTube videos
The Fallacy of ‘Openness and Tolerance’
How the GOP Tax Bill Would Close an Absurd Loophole
Two addiction counselors die of overdose at Pennsylvania facility
Israel to build thousands of new homes in East Jerusalem
Taliban storm Afghan police compound, kill 5 police
July 25 forecast: Sunny, with cloud of impeachment for Trump…
Hamas Seeks the Elimination of the State of Israel
Facebook Banned Me for Tying Islamic Terror to…Well, Islam
Baby Charlie Gard's Parents and Doctors Haggle over Details of His Final Days
Napolitano's University of California hid $175M while demanding money, audit says
Goldman CEO to Trump: Don't scrap Dodd-Frank!
House will vote to stop Boeing sales to Iran
Cancer-detecting gum may soon be available
NTSB heads to site of New Jersey plane crash
CHILDREN AMONG THE DEAD Report: 10 of the 29 Coptic Christians killed in Egypt bus ambush were kids
UPDATE: BRAZIL MEAT SCANDAL DEEPENS AS CHINA, EU, CHILE BAR IMPORTS…
As St. Louis Erupts, Democrats Own It
Sadiq Khan Squelches Freedom of Thought and Expression
Clinton suggests she will continue to speak out
Trump and the Canary Trap
Sharing the NATO Arrangement
New Finland prime minister is 34!
'League' star defends himself
H.W. BUSH HOSPITALIZED Former president ‘is going to be fine’: spokesman
Florida boy, 10, arrested 4 times in 6 weeks for allegedly stealing cars
RNC takes victory lap in wake of Trump upset
Federal lawmakers seek to deregulate gun silencers
Democrats rebrand under new slogan – will their product sell? – Republicans dismiss Dems' 'better deal' with ad targeting Pelosi – OPINION: Dems' new slogan like bad pizza slice slathered with 40-year-old ingredients and almost no meat – VIDEO: Dems' new slogan sounds oddly familiar
Officials: Police mum on school janitor's rape conviction
Facebook FINED over privacy
PATRIOTS JOLTED BY HOME GAME LOSS…
DICTATOR'S END GAME Who is Kim Jong Un? And what does he want?
Trump's CIA pick supports domestic surveillance, opposes Iran deal
Year after Moonves, 'toxic' culture remains in CBS TV…
Baby born with 4 legs, 2 spines recovering after reconstructive surgery
'WE HIT A HOME RUN' Trump delivers message to US troops, wraps first overseas trip as president
HBO OKs Watergate series…
Forget Balancing the Budget – Let's Think Big
SNAP: Passenger tries biting flight attendant before jumping from plane…
Newsrooms hyping most predictable event of 2016
Tanks a bullion! Man finds gold bars buried in military vehicle
An Epic Lack of Congressional Fortitude
Jobless claims are running at a 44-year low
REINCE RESIGNS: Priebus quits as White House chief of staff, DHS chief John Kelly named as replacement
CLAIMS QUESTIONED Woman accused of making up alleged sex attacks
Not All Stings Work: On the War James O'Keefe Is Winning
Extinct tiger spotted?
Reporters hit Trump for blowing off CNN reporter
ESPN’S BAD CALL Website posted poem honoring fugitive cop killer
Man accused of chaining woman 'like a dog' pleads guilty to 7 murders
Soros has some interesting thoughts on Trump and the media
Pope calls for 'zero tolerance' of child sex abuse
Biggest dino print found
Why Betsy DeVos is visiting this Ohio school today
NYC Coffee Startup Tamps Down Bro Culture by Hiring Philosopher…
A Quick Fix to Restore Faith in Democracy
Maryland robbery thwarted; suspect in standoff
Bannon asks conservatives to 'have our back'
The Culture Police
Twitter creator laments role of social media in election of Trump
Headaches abound for Minnesota man declared dead by the IRS 29 years ago
CRYING FOUL Liberals focus on Trump in 'March for Truth' rallies
Afghanistan forces fighting ISIS take a slow-and-steady approach
MEETING QUESTIONED Report: Kushner met with sanctioned Russia bankers
Trading glitch briefly sets Apple, Amazon and Microsoft stock prices at $123.47 – G-20 watchdog says no letup in correspondent banking decline
How to burn fat naturally
Arizona girl found in storage box: Cousin stands trial on murder, abuse charges
Texas woman granted clemency by Obama last year is back in prison
Bill O’Reilly Back at Fox News – For One Night Only?
Sean Hannity: Trump 'a little too sensitive at times'
Report: No significant intel from Yemen raid that killed SEAL
Watch: Horse battles gator at Florida park
Hurricane cakes: ok or no way?
Shark stalked bloody victim as rescuers rushed to SoCal beach…
'I made it': Student with Down syndrome learns he's accepted to college
Galaxy's first 'space burger'
Good Riddance, Evangelicalism Incorporated
Japanese restaurants rocket to top of best in world list…
Trump talks tough on trade, Dems, business listen
MICHELLE O: It's surreal…
Lana Del Rey witchcraft attempt against Trump…
'7th Heaven' star: Not a prude
The Davis-Bacon Act of 1931 and the Breakdown of the Black Family
Putin: TV Trump very different from real Trump
Saturn probe stuns scientists
Bannon predicts '50 years' of GOP rule if Trump delivers
Moms have a drinking problem
DC mayor signs assisted suicide bill
Mount Rainier caps swarm of weekend seismicity with 3.6 mag quake…
The Truth Goes Marching On
China introduces mandatory face scans for phone users…
Passenger terror as plane engine DISINTEGRATES mid-air on flight from Paris to LA…
Fasting for Christmas
Mnuchin, Price nominations stalled after Democrats boycott vote
The United States Must Leave the UN Human Rights Council
'TRYING NOT TO VOMIT' Professor tweets disgust over respect for troops
Football fans boo Castro supporters
Trump should reward middle class with tax cuts: former GE CEO Jack Welch
Nigerian president: Boko Haram 'crushed,' driven out of last stronghold
Bill in Congress would pressure Palestinian gov't to cut off terror-tied payments – VIDEO: Eric Shawn reports — Taylor Force and terror money
The Tehran Attacks: Beginning of the End for Assad?
Fired engineers seek federal probe…
Student loan debt up more than 450 percent since 2003
New Arizona Development Bans Residents From Bringing Cars…
Feds Probe Laundering, Obstruction, Campaign Violations…
Beats Trump by 6 points in hypothetical matchup: poll…
Iran's Ahmadinejad to run for president
DiCaprio Responds to Brazil President Claim He Funded Amazon Wildfires…
Hits out at poor understanding of music…
Shia LaBeouf arrested in Georgia for public intoxication
This anti-populism cartoon misses the mark
Inventing the Political Center
South Korea fires shots at North Korea after object crosses border – COMPLETE COVERAGE NORTH KOREA CRISIS
118-year-old painting discovered in Antarctica
Disease, defects and danger: The unhappy truth behind pet cloning…
Puerto Rico mulls political status in new referendum
NYC's De Blasio: 'Children Will Die' Because of Trump's Budget
Botched anti-measles campaign kills 15 children in South Sudan
Conservative clean energy could be Trump's climate plan
ROGER AILES DEAD Former Fox News chairman and CEO has died at 77
Toxic Humanism
A Half-Century of Adolescent Agitators
'Flip' star's bikini backlash
Reversal of Aaron Hernandez's murder conviction appalls victim's family
Mulvaney: We're taking the tax code 'back to a blank piece of paper'
How Regulations Made California's Fires Worse
Country star: I refuse to
New York illegal immigrant with possible MS-13 ties stands trial in break-in, sex assault
Cats to be put on leashes to protect wildlife? EU says No…
NEWT GINGRICH Democrats turn to red tape to stop President Trump
Colorado mom says baby overheated while United jet sat on tarmac for hours
Repeal Obama's Net Neutrality — ObamaCare for the Internet
High Court allows strict enforcement of Trump ban – Trump travel ban: Timeline of a legal journey
Appeals court sides with Congress over bank records…
If Trump Loses Bannon, Trump Loses the Presidency
Louis C.K. tells Israeli audience he'd 'rather be in Auschwitz than NYC'….
New York's 'island of the dead' to welcome more living…
MacArthur's Spies: The Heroes of the Philippines
UPDATE: BBC defends gory new drama after viewers left 'traumatized'…
Lawmaker: DOJ considering investigation into Sheriff Clarke's jail
Making the Clintons Pay
At least 58 killed in suspected chemical attack in Syria
The Bankruptcy of One Free Grope Politics
The Progressive Tea Party that Never Was
Robert Mueller Adopts Stalinist Tactics
McDonald's expands fresh-never-frozen beef push
Upton shows off in blue bikini
Mueller Investigation: Illegal 'Fruit of the Poisonous Tree?'
Reality Winner: Can the government prevent more intelligence leaks?
Mexicans, not Mexico, might pay for Trump's wall
New York Times editor: Trump is the best thing ever to happen to our subscriptions
The Cultural Roots of Trumpism
Farmers in Crisis Turn to High-Interest Loans…
Wells Fargo asks for lawsuits to be arbitrated outside court
Democrats to study election 'autopsy' at Baltimore retreat
White House rips Senate GOP for 'rubber-stamping' Trump Cabinet picks
The Trouble with Conservatism
Illegal immigrant deported 15 times arrested in hit-run crash that hurt 6-year-old boy
4 Vietnam War veterans receive Silver Star for 1972 rescue mission
SCORSESE Lectures: Don't Watch 'IRISHMAN' on Your Phone!
1 dead, 1 wounded after shooting at Miami restaurant
California gas tax hike prompts fierce backlash from the right
Tillerson: Asia allies 'critical' for addressing North Korean threat
Democrat senator drops F-bomb while criticizing Republicans, AHCA
The Left Is 'Spinning' Out of Control
Is America a Christian Nation?
Spicer: 'Make no mistake,' the border wall will be built
Waiting for Garrow: New Obama Biography Due This Week
OPINION: Liberal news outlets work overtime to hide a huge Democratic scandal
Calls to national suicide hotlines reportedly up after Trump victory
Tonight’s the Night: Can Fox News Get Its Mojo Back?
Amber Alert: Search is on for 8-year-old Wisconsin boy who may be with armed father
SETTING THE FIRE 3 arrested in blaze that destroyed interstate bridge
Feds say economy grew 3.5 percent in Q3
GROWING INVESTIGATION Senators expand probe of Trump, Russia ties
Duhamel: I WON’T talk politics
The Democrats’ Pathology
Howard Dean endorses long shot Pete Buttigieg for DNC chairman
Israel's drone industry becomes global force…
